Skip to content

Hiring Your First Employee

Quick Summary: Most DPC practices can operate solo for years. When you do hire, start small - a part-time medical assistant or office manager is usually the right first step. Don't rush this decision.

Do You Actually Need to Hire?

Before hiring, ask yourself:

Challenge your assumptions: - Can you handle 400-600 patients solo? Many DPC physicians do. - Is your time constraint real or perceived? - Would systems improvements or technology help more than an employee? - Could you outsource specific tasks instead of hiring?

Signs you might be ready: - Consistently working more hours than sustainable - Turning away patients due to capacity - Administrative tasks preventing patient care - Phone management becoming overwhelming - You want to take a real vacation

Signs you're NOT ready: - Panel under 300 patients - Not yet profitable or barely breaking even - "It would be nice to have help" (not a business need) - Trying to grow faster than sustainable

First Hire Options

Medical Assistant (Part-Time)

Best for: Practices with 400+ patients wanting to increase efficiency

Typical duties: - Room patients, vitals - Prepare for visits - Simple procedures assistance - Phone triage - Prescription refill coordination - Lab result follow-up

Typical cost: $15-25/hour, 15-25 hours/week = $900-2,500/month

Office Manager / Administrative Assistant (Part-Time)

Best for: Physicians who want to focus purely on clinical work

Typical duties: - Phone management - Scheduling - Membership billing - New patient enrollment - Correspondence - Supply ordering

Typical cost: $18-30/hour, 10-20 hours/week = $700-2,400/month

Virtual Assistant (Remote)

Best for: Practices wanting minimal overhead and flexibility

Typical duties: - Phone answering - Scheduling - Insurance verification (for patients) - Prior authorizations - Administrative tasks

Typical cost: $15-35/hour, as-needed basis

The Hiring Process

1. Define the Role

Write a clear job description including: - Specific duties (be detailed) - Hours and schedule - Required skills and experience - Nice-to-have qualifications - Your practice culture

2. Determine Compensation

Research local rates for: - Medical assistants: $15-25/hour - Office managers: $18-35/hour - Consider benefits (or not for part-time)

For part-time (<30 hours): Usually no benefits required

3. Recruit Candidates

Sources: - Indeed, ZipRecruiter (broad reach) - Local medical assistant programs - Word of mouth (patients, colleagues) - Local healthcare job boards - Facebook local job groups

Your DPC advantage: Many healthcare workers are burned out. Emphasize: - Small, personal practice - Meaningful work - No insurance hassles - Better work-life balance

4. Interview Process

Phone screen (15 minutes): - Basic qualifications - Schedule compatibility - Salary expectations - Why interested in DPC

In-person interview (30-60 minutes): - Detailed experience discussion - Scenario questions - Culture fit assessment - Questions they have

Working interview (2-4 hours, paid): - Actual practice tasks - Interaction with you - See them in action - Best predictor of success

5. Background and References

  • Reference checks (at least 2)
  • Background check if required
  • Verify credentials/certifications
  • Drug screening if applicable

Employment Basics

Employment Type

W-2 Employee: - You withhold taxes - You pay employer taxes (FICA match) - You control schedule and methods - Most common for ongoing roles

1099 Independent Contractor: - They handle their own taxes - Limited control over methods - Risk of misclassification - Generally not appropriate for regular staff

Required Documentation

  • W-4 (employee tax withholding)
  • I-9 (employment eligibility)
  • State tax forms (varies by state)
  • Direct deposit authorization
  • Employee handbook acknowledgment

Required Postings

Check your state requirements for: - Minimum wage poster - OSHA poster - Workers' compensation notice - Other state-specific postings

Insurance Considerations

Workers' compensation: Required in most states (even for 1 employee)

Employment practices liability: Optional but recommended

Update business insurance: Notify your carrier of employees

Payroll Options

DIY Options

Gusto: $40/month + $6/employee - Easy to use - Handles all filings - Good for small practices

QuickBooks Payroll: $45-125/month - Integrates with QB accounting - Full service available

Full-Service Payroll

ADP, Paychex: More expensive but handle everything - Better for multiple employees - Include HR resources

Accountant-Handled

Many small practice accountants will handle payroll - Usually included in monthly fee - Convenient if you already have a relationship

Training Your First Hire

Week 1: Orientation

  • Practice overview and DPC philosophy
  • EMR training
  • Phone protocols
  • HIPAA training
  • Basic procedures

Weeks 2-4: Supervised Practice

  • Shadow you during patient encounters
  • Gradual independence on tasks
  • Regular feedback
  • Adjust training as needed

Ongoing

  • Weekly check-ins initially
  • Clear communication channels
  • Performance feedback
  • Continued education

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  1. Hiring too soon - Wait until truly needed
  2. Hiring a friend/family member - Professional boundaries matter
  3. Not checking references - Always verify
  4. Unclear expectations - Document everything
  5. Skipping the working interview - Best predictor of fit
  6. Overpaying or underpaying - Research local rates
  7. No written policies - Create simple employee handbook

When It's Not Working

If your hire isn't working out:

  1. Address issues early - Don't let problems fester
  2. Document concerns - Written warnings if needed
  3. Set clear improvement timeline - 30-60 days
  4. Know your state laws - Termination requirements vary
  5. Consult attorney if unsure - Employment law is complex

Alternatives to Hiring

Before hiring, consider:

  • Outsourced answering service: $100-300/month
  • Virtual scribes: Per-visit or monthly
  • Billing service: If you do any fee-for-service
  • Cleaning service: Don't clean your own office
  • Technology automation: Reduce administrative burden

Resources

[!NOTE] Employment law varies significantly by state. Consult with an employment attorney or HR professional for state-specific requirements.

Most successful DPC practices operated solo for years before hiring. There's no rush - hire when you truly need it, not because you think you should.